Open preprint reviews by Alfonso Martinez Arias

A defined platform of human peri-gastrulation-like biological fate patterning reveals coordination between Reaction-Diffusion and Positional-Information

Mukul Tewary, Joel E Ostblom, Nika Shakiba, Peter W Zandstra

Very interesting study that complements well the work from the Siggia and Brivanlou groups (e.g Warmflash et al. 2014) referred to in the text. What catches my eye is the requirement for Nodal which is not reported in Warmflash et al. though in that work they use conditioned medium which may contain some TGF-ß. The more controlled culture conditions of this study allow details like this to come out. As indicated by the authors the need for Nodal is likely to be related to its requirement for T/Bra expression; but there is also a requirement for BMP i.e. the full pattern requires both Nodal and BMP. I wonder if the authors have tested a requirement for Wnt in the process.

The current views of the patterning of the mouse epiblast (the main reference we have for human embryos) suggests that BMP initiates the expression of Nodal and Wnt3 in the epiblast and that Wnt3 increases the expression of Nodal, as well as its activity by regulating the expression of the coreceptor Cripto. Then, both Nodal and Wnt signalling lead to the expression of T/Bra. Observations in hESC differentiation in culture suggest that this relationships might be transferable to human embryos or gastruloids. So, just wonder if the observation of the interdependence of BMP and Nodal does not have Wnt signalling in the middle. Perhaps, in the experiments BMP signalling is not strong enough to activate Nodal expression, thought it activates enough Wnt3 to get the system ready for Nodal. Nodal would then kick in its autoregulation which would be sustained by the Wnt induced by BMP. If this were the case, inhibition of Wnt signalling will alter, and perhaps abolish, the patterning event. Also, Wnt signalling might be able to substitute for BMP i.e. the pattern could be driven by Wnt and Nodal. Just wonder if the authors have looked at this. Alternatively, it could be that the circuitry differs between mESC and hESCs as suggested by Etoc et al (2016) for the case of BMP and Noggin.

A second issue concerns the evidence provided in Figure 5E for periodicity as predicted by a change of the length scale in a Turing system. Is that spotty pattern rather than concentric rings, what one could predict in two dimensions?

show less