Preprint reviews by Richard Malham

A simple proposal for the publication of journal citation distributions

Vincent Lariviere, Veronique Kiermer, Catriona J MacCallum, Marcia McNutt, Mark Patterson, Bernd Pulverer, Sowmya Swaminathan, Stuart Taylor, Stephen Curry

Review posted on 08th July 2016

I already noted these in a comment on this blog post ( but wanted to also raise them here

Stephen: When revising the article, I would suggest looking at the existing recommendations in these two reports (particularly relevant to the recommendations section at the end of the Discussion section)

‘Evaluating Interdisciplinary Research: a practical guide’, from Durham University’s Institute of Advanced Study (July 2015)

‘Improving recognition of team science contributions in biomedical
research careers’, from the Academy of Medical Sciences (March 2016)

show less