Completed on 25 Apr 2017 by Björn Grüning .
Login to endorse this review.
Sourced from https://oup.silverchair-cdn.com/oup/backfile/Content_public/Journal/gigascience/6/7/10.1093_gigascience_gix042/4/gix042_Reviewer-1-Report-(Original-Submission).pdf?Expires=1517197779&Signature=d~aGnriEytLCvamJUeLBPIjvCYFmMtYhrztTiqBxpShROHdSzCHLtSat9IZyZ3I-BgZqBCBy~7pD3nAF2Bj0MAK9tv6IEICX-sSgoxoiERRYpgGHvLn837lDmjfKpjq82jf9zWKpNo-9iM7W2Qk~sx7HMcwwpMHsGDyXcKyl5cYhlFOSgRfelIEozwNAzWSHJBebAqJVlzogeYK6v2zBlFcEfgthoyFOtjW9TCW-J9OYUTDvCNPkZTEDEYPedCpMCq2S-H6G-nvWovIXfglWAj~fjqShBb8vrQyk7ICwIfP9XY4NF65KdwIcUAzB1WY7gjeXMfBA605KFLVN3HOEiQ__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAIUCZBIA4LVPAVW3Q Re-review of a previously rejected manuscript. I have read the revised version and it is better then before. At least they discuss now that there are other projects that do exactly the same but in a more standardised way.
They don't seem to know that you can control Galaxy via an API and solve their problems that way, but this is not the scope here
I just wish people would study the field better before they start to develop something.